What are some typical problems
encountered with temperature measurement systems?Broadly problems
usually fall into one or more of five areas: emissivity related,
environment related, reflected radiation problems, incorrect signal
processing, and design/selection of equipment. In brief, these are:
1. Emissivity related problems. There are many types of
emissivity related problems. Emissivity can vary with wavelength,
product curvature, product surface roughness, viewing angle,
temperature, surface film effects, and a few more obscure items. And you
can't measure an accurate temperature without knowing the emissivity
value to use. For more on this, click here on
EMISSIVITY
2. Environment related problems: Certain atmospheric gases,
water vapor or steam or particles can absorb or scatter radiation from
the sight path between the radiation thermometer and surface to be
viewed. This causes an erratic low temperature reading for brightness
units and can cause either a high or low reading for ratio units. It is
sometimes also forgotten that power line fluctuations or noise, and too
high or low of an ambient temperature can cause a radiation thermometer
to read incorrectly. Excessive vibration can actually shake units apart.
For more on this, click here ENVIRONMENT.
3. Reflected radiation problems: For opaque materials,
reflectivity is equal to 1.0 minus emissivity. If there is any source of
external radiation that could reflect off the area being viewed, it
could reflect into the radiation thermometer, adding to the radiation
from the surface. This will cause the indicated temperature to be
incorrectly high because of the additional radiation received. Two
common problems are that the area viewed may be lit by sodium vapor
lamps or illuminated through an overhead window. Both contain infrared
radiation. Another problem is attempting to view material being heated
in a furnace. Yet another problem (and a big one!) is attempting to
measure the temperature of reflective product that may only be one or
two hundred degrees hotter than room temperature. It is often forgotten
that at these temperatures, everything around will emit infrared
radiation and you will have a problem with reflected radiation,
guaranteed! For more on this, click on
REFLECTIONS
4. Signal processing. In many applications, the
radiation received by the radiation thermometer may fluctuate, most
commonly because of sight path interference or absorption. There is a
general rule: anything interfering with the sight path will cause a
reduction in radiation received. I've seen people try to use a lower
emissivity setting combined with signal averaging, but that's the wrong
approach as the amount of interference is not constant. A better
solution (if the interference cannot be avoided) is to use the smallest
spot size possible combined with "peak picking" methods. Other problems
can include variations of emissivity with product shape, processing
or product roughness, which may be solved using imbedded computers
combined with other measurements of the product characteristics. For
more on this, click on SIGNAL PROCESSING
5. Equipment selection & design: Each application requires
careful consideration as to what equipment and overall design will work
best considering all the possible problems listed above. A large number
of choices exist in the basic radiation thermometer type (fiber optic
versus refractive versus reflective optics, wavelength, spot size,
single or multiwavelength, computer adjusted) which must all be
carefully considered. For more on this, click on
EQUIPMENT/DESIGN